The Integrator Blog
Home
Share |
about
Contact Me, Experience, Mission, Sabbatical in Central America, plus
Editorial Advisory Board
Columnists
Michael Levin
Taylor Walsh
background resources in PDF
Insurance, Integrative Clinics, Industry Summit Reports, News Files '99-'04
some organization links
Professions, Academia, Research, Policy
some CAM/IM publication links
Electronic, Peer-Reviewed, Blogs, More
Bradly Jacobs, MD, MPH, Revolution Health Blog
supported conference
Institute for Health & Productivity Management - Integrative/Complementary Healthcare
Model Whole Practice Study Finds Naturopathic Care Effective, Cost Saving for Canadian Employer PDF Print E-mail
Written by John Weeks   
Friday, 20 August 2010

Model Whole Practice Study Finds Treatment by Naturopathic Doctors Effective & Cost-Saving for Canada Post Employees with Cardiovascular Disease

Summary: Preliminary results from a randomized controlled pragmatic trial of the whole practice of naturopathic medicine for Canada Post employees with elevated cardiovascular risk found treatment by integrative naturopathic doctors to be both effective and cost-saving. Naturopathic treatment produced an overall $1025 cost benefit per participant. The results were reported by Dugald Seely, Bsc, ND, MSc and economist Patricia Herman, MS, ND, PhD, on August 12, 2010 at the conference of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians. The methods for researching this whole practice, individualized treatment are a model for all  integrative practitioners, whether integrative MDs/DOs, broad scope DCs, AOM practitioners or other multi-modal care-givers for whom reductive trials fail to capture their practices. The model provides critical information for healthcare decision makers. For many in the naturopathic profession, the outcomes are celebrated as a potential game-changer in their efforts to expand inclusion of their services by employers, public agencies and insurers.
Send your comments to
for publication in a future Integrator.

Image
Major employer backs study
Preliminary results from a randomized controlled pragmatic trial of the whole practice of naturopathic medicine for patients with elevated cardiovascular risk found treatment by integrative naturopathic doctors to be both effective and cost saving.
The study was engaged by researchers associated with the Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine (CCNM) for Canada Post, the Canadian postal service.

The Canada Post employees who were patients of naturopathic doctors showed significant reductions in levels of cardiovascular risk and incidence of metabolic syndrome. They also found benefits across numerous biometric and self-reported health-related markers. The "total societal cost savings" during the year were estimated to be $1025 per employee.

Image
CCNM's Seely: Lead researcher for the study on Canada Post employees
The data were reported on August 12, 2010 at the annual conference of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians. The principal researcher on the study was Dugald Seely, BSc, ND, MSc, director of research for CCNM. Seely's report was entitled "Naturopathic Treatment for the Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease: A Whole System Randomized Pragmatic Trial."

Economist Patricia Herman, MS, ND, PhD, led the cost analysis and reported her findings as "Cost-Effectiveness of Naturopathic Treatment for the Prevention of cardiovascular Disease." Herman co-authored the economics paper for the 2009 Summit on Integrative Medicine and the Health of the Public.


Concluded Herman: "If we examine only direct costs, it looks like the cost of naturopathic care per unit reduction in the risk of cardiovascular disease is somewhere between that of aspirin and that of statin drugs." The significant overall cost savings to the employer were found once factors such as absenteeism and
presenteeism were included.

___________________________

At a Glance:
Cost & Effectiveness of the Whole Practice of Naturopathic Doctors
in Preventing Cardiovascular Disease
- Preliminary Findings

Study led by Dugald Seely, BSc, ND, MSc & Patricia Herman, ND, PhD


General Information
   
Partner/Subjects
  Canada Post/Canadian Union of Postal Workers
Research institution
  Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine
Principal investigator
  Dugald Seely, BSc, ND, MSc
Lead cost investigator
  Patricia Herman, MS, ND, PhD
Study type
  Randomized controlled pragmatic  trial
Total subjects
  246 (124 to treatment, 122 usual care)
Recommended therapies   Suggestions individualized to each patient
with a focus on dietary, lifestyle and
supplement interventions. Some key
examples include nutrition (whole foods
focus), fish or fish oil consumption,
sleep (7 hr/night), counseling, stress
reduction (deep breathing), exercise
(30 minutes/day for
5 days/wk)

Adherence: "About 80%"

Naturopathic visits   7 in one year; weeks 0, 4, 8, 18, 26, 35, 52

Clinical Measures

   
Measures  
  • Framingham cardiovascular risk profile
  • Incidence of metabolic syndrome (MS)
  • MYMOP patient-centered outcomes

Clinical Outcomes    
Clinical outcomes
(primary)
 
  • 27% favorable difference in MS
  • 3.6% favorable difference in risk
  • ND group 5.5 years younger in "CV years"

Clinical outcomes
(secondary)
  Self-reports via MYMOP found improvement
in multiple areas: fatigue, sleep, weight,
stress, allergic symptoms, hypertension,
coffee consumption, muscoloskeletal problems,
etc.

Est. impact on 10 year risk
of cardiovascular disease
 
  • 3.3 fewer works out of 100 will not have a
            major event
  • "at least 1 person who would
           have died will not have died."

Cost Measures
   
Direct cost measures
 
  • Direct medical costs of ND services
           (prescribed supplements included)
  • Visits to conventional physicians (MDs)
  • Visits to other practitioners (DC, PT, 
           massage, acupuncture
  • Medications
  • Supplements patients use on their own

Indirect cost measures
 
Cost Outcomes
   
 Direct costs for 1 year per each
healthy year of life saved over
the next 10 years
   $1477 Naturopathic treatment

Compared to:
$4239-$7829 smoking cessation programs
$626 aspirin
$6631 anti-hypertensive medications
$6134 statins

 Indirect costs
  Absenteeism: up 10 hours/yr/participant
for treatment; up 2 hours/yr for usual care

Presenteeism: Gained the equivalent of
just over 7 additional productive days
(57 hours)  per year per participant
for treatment; gained 2 hours/yr for
usual care

 
Total societal cost savings

   
$1025/participant


All data from notes of August 12, 2010 presentations by
Seely & Herman at the AANP convention.

  _____________________________


The study was the 4th in a series that Seely's team has engaged through a collaboration with the management and union of Canada Post. The relationship was established through CCNM president Bob Bernhardt, PhD. (See #3 at this link for notes on an earlier back pain study with economic outcomes that was part of this study series and presented at a conference of the Institute for Health and Productivity Management.)

Herding cats: Individualized treatment around suggested best practices

Image
Herman: Led cost analysis
A challenge in examining the whole practice of naturopathic physicians is convincing doctors to use a standardized protocol. First, naturopathic care is philosophically oriented toward individualizing treatment based on the doctor's read of the patient and such issues as the patient's readiness for change. In addition, given the diversity of therapeutic options available to naturopathic physicians, and the individual dispositions of the practitioners themselves, the whole person protocols of different doctors often offer a wide variety of approaches and treatments.

Seely's team approached these challenges with a unique strategy. First, they intentionally chose to use doctors with just 2-5 years in their practices. This group was expected to be more open to modifying treatment than clinicians who have been in practice longer. The researchers then required the involved doctors to attend a training session in which 4 respected cardiovascular experts presented information on best practices in naturopathic treatment for reducing cardiovascular risk.

Once the training was completed, however, the practitioners were allowed to practice as they felt most appropriate. The researchers promoted a lifestyle-oriented approach with specific targets in some areas, yet protocols were not mandated. Seely indicated that the participating doctors were comfortable with this method. No information was presented as to whether the strategy, in fact, drew the practitioners toward a mean.

Discussion elements and "decision research"

Seely noted that while practitioners were allowed to individualize treatment, a strong focus was on lifestyle issues: "We wanted to examine holistic, naturopathic care. We had a very, very strong dietary focus."

Image
Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine: Study's research institution
Herman explained the value of including the cost dimensions: "Cost effectiveness adds another dimension for decision makers considering alternative CVD prevention strategies.
" In this case, the primary audiences who may use the outcomes for decisions about their healthcare strategy are Canada Post and the postal workers union.

Herman cautioned repeatedly that the findings were preliminary. She also noted that the cost outcomes are limited, given the limitations of the one-year time frame. What long-term impact might these lifestyle-oriented interventions have? In addition, Seely noted that the findings were limited due to the "surrogate measures" that were utilized: "Estimating risk is not a hard outcome."  The researchers are preparing the outcomes for submission to a peer-reviewed journal. Seely noted that he and his team are in discussion with Canada Post on a follow-up study.


Comments: A common denominator of much of integrative practice is a desire for greater acceptance, coverage, use and inclusion. This is true whether we speak of the whole practices of integrative medicine by MDs/DOs, multi-modal care from broad scope chiropractors, holistic approaches of nurses, applications of acupuncture and Oriental medicine practitioners or, as here, the work of naturopathic physicians. In order to advance, these fields need to develop data that helps decision-makers on coverage and inclusion.

   
  The message to employers is not about
lifestyle interventions or fish oil but rather:

Send your employees to naturopathic
doctors, and you get effective and
 cost-effective treatment in the very
 costly area of cardiovascular disease.

It is in this context that I refer to this study as a model. First, the Canada Post trial is not only randomized and controlled. It is also pragmatic. The attempt was to capture the real world practice of naturopathic doctors. The message to employers is not about lifestyle interventions or fish oil but rather: Send your employees to naturopathic doctors, and you get effective and cost-effective treatment in the very costly area of cardiovascular disease.

Note that the elements that support decision-makers are not just whether the treatments are effectiveness, but whether they are cost-effective. Notably, the costs included should also be sensitive to the interests of employers as decision-makers. Examined are not merely direct costs but also absenteeism and most importantly, presenteeism. This latter measure, virtually absent from the whole body of NIH NCCAM-funded work, has been estimated to reflect 60% of the health-related costs to employers according to Ron Goertzel, PhD
of the Cornell University Institute for Health and Productivity Studies.

The report of these outcomes was greeted with great excitement by the members of naturopathic profession. Carlo Calabrese, ND, MPH, executive director of the Naturopathic Physicians Research Institute, declared the report the most significant news of the convention. Others spoke of the Seely-Herman data as potentially a "game-changer" in the profession's efforts to make its case as a health-creating and cost-saving discipline.

The integrative practice fields would serve their own missions by embracing this example of what might be called decision research. Each field could make exceptional use of a dozen such game-changer studies. Variations on this model with diverse conditions and practitioner types would be the optimal research agenda for quickly understanding how and in what ways whole person, integrative practices can make a significant difference in our health care delivery.
_______________

Disclosure: Both Seely and Herman are Scientific and Clinical Advisers to the Naturopathic Physicians Research Institute on which I serve in a leadership capacity.

Send your comments to
for publication in a future Integrator.


Last Updated ( Thursday, 26 August 2010 )
< Prev   Next >
Subscribe to the Newsletter
Search
Advertisement
Advertisement
 
 
Advertisement
Sponsors
NCMIC Group
AMI Group
Integrative Practitioner
voluntary contributions
Support the work!
Archive
All Integrator Round-ups
Integrator Top 10 Lists 2006-2013
Issues #116-#118 - Oct-Dec 2013
Issues #113-#115 July-Sept 2013
Issues #110-#112 April-June 2013
Issues #108-#109 Jan-March 2013
Issue #105-#107 Oct-Dec 2012
Issues #102-#104 - July-Sept 2012
Issues #99-#101 - April-June 2012
Issues #96-#98-Jan-March 2012
Issues #94-#95 Nov-Dec 2011
Issues #92-#93 Sept-Oct 2011
Issues #90 and #91 - July-Aug 2011
Issues #88 and #89 - May-June 2011
Issues #86 and #87 - March-April 2011
Issues #84 and #85 - Jan-Feb 2011
Issues #82 and #83 - Nov-Dec 2010
Issues #80 & #81 - Sept Oct 2010
Issues #78 & #79 - July August 2010
Issues #76 & #77 - May June 2010
Issues #74 & #75 - March-April 2010
Issues #73 & #73 - Jan-Feb 2010
Issues #69, #70 & #71 - Nov-Dec 2009
Issues #67 and #68 - Sept-Oct 2009
Issues #65 and #66 - July-August 2009
Issues #63-#64 - May-June 2009
Issues #60-#62 - March-April 2009
Issues #57-#59 - Jan-Feb 2009
Issues #55-#56 - Nov-Dec 2008
Issues #51-#54 - Sept-Oct 2008
Issues #47-#50 - July-August 2008
Issues #46 & -#47 - May-June 2008
Issues #43-#45 Mar-April 2008
Issues #41 & #42 - Feb 2008
Issues #39 & #40 - Dec-Jan '08
Issues #37 & #38 - Nov 2007
Issues #35 & #36 - Oct 2007
Issues #33 & #34 - Sept 2007
Issues #30-#32 - July-Aug 2007
Issues #28 & #29 - June 2007
Issues #26 and #27 - May 2007
Issue #25 - April 2007
Issues # 23 & #24 - March 2007
Issues #21 and #22 - Feb 2007
Issues #19 and & 20 - Jan 2007
Issues #17 and #18 - Dec 2006
Issues #15 and #16 - Nov 2006
Issues #13 and #14 - Oct 2006
Issues #11 and #12- Sept 2006
Issues #9 and #10 - Aug 2006
Issues #7 and #8 - July 2006
Issues #5 and #6 - June 2006
Issues #3 and #4 - May 2006
Issues #1 and #2 - April 2006
All Articles by Subject: 2006
All Articles by Subject: Jan-June 2007
IAYT-Sponsored Series on the Future of Yoga Therapy