Research Updates: IN-CAM Outcomes Tools, Next CAHCIM Conference, MTF/AANP Awards, plus SAR
Written by John Weeks
Tuesday, 10 April 2007
Research Initiatives Update: IN-CAM Outcomes Tools, Next CAHCIM Conference, MTF & AANP Promote Research by Practitioners, Acupuncture Research 10 Years After ...
Summary: Happily, IN-CAM, the Canadian research network, has taken on the important work of developing a data base on outcomes tools that fit with complementary, integrative and whole person approaches .. CAHCIM announces the dates and place for its second major research conference .. The Massage Therapy Foundation and AANP offer awards to stimulate research by practitioners ... 10 years after the NIH Consensus Conference on Acupuncture, the Society for Acupuncture Research will reflect on advances, direction ...
Send your comments to
for inclusion in a future Your Comments article.
1. Canadian Group IN-CAM Gathers Outcomes Instruments for Whole Systems Research
The Canadian Interdisciplinary Network for Complementary and Alternative Medicine Research (IN-CAM) described in its recent Bulletin(February
2007) an initiative to gather outcomes measures that may be optimal for
CAM research. The article by whole systems research leader Marja Verhoef, PhD (whose work was noted here in the Integrator)
is entitled: 'Focus: What Outcome Measures Do We Need in CAM
Research? Development of the Canadian In-CAM Outcomes Data Base."
Verhoef describes the goal of the data base:
"Researchers
evaluating the outcomes of CAM interventions must use psychometrically
sound, relevant outcome measures. Given the complexity of CAM
interventions, in particular CAM whole systems, it is likely that for
different interventions, different outcome measures are needed, and
that some studies may need more than one outcome measure to assess the
potential changes that could take place. However, locating reliable, comprehensive information on a wide range of outcome measures can be tedious and time consuming. "
Whole systems researcher Marja Verhoef, PhD
Using
a survey in which 164 members participated, the team began to identify
the outcome domains for which instruments are needed. The group is
developing a website and is working to "populate it" with the
instruments. No time frame for availability was provided. Verhoef
writes that one goal is also to "encourage
researchers to develop outcome measures in domains for which, thus far,
no outcome instruments are available. This is an exceptionally useful
project. I wrote to Verhoef congratulating her but also noting my deep
concern that there were no economic outcomes noted. The project has had
support from the John and Lotte Hecht Foundation.
Comment: I'm thinking that the reason it is in Canada and not the United States that this project - which respects both health systems and an outcomes orientation - has been embraced is linked to Canada's outcomes-oriented, governmental healthcare system. Got an opinion?
The planning team, led this next round by Adi Haramati, PhD, of Georgetown University,
made efforts in the first round to include researchers from other
professions. The organizers were successful, with strong contingents on
hand of both presenters and attendees representing chiropractic,
massage, acupuncture and Oriental medicine, naturopathic medicine and
Yoga therapy. The conference in 2006 helped shape numerous ongoing
discussions, including an international dialogue on whole systems research.
Put the dates on your calendar, even if you only have a peripheral relationship to research. Ben Kligler, MD, MPH and I had a chance to present some research from the National Education Dialogue
at the 2006 meeting. Here's a guarantee that you will be intrigued by
the content, dialogue and the relationship opportunities. There's
nothing else like this out there.
3. Massage and Naturopathic Organizations Promotes In-Office Research
The Massage Therapy Foundation recently announced that it has a Practitioner Case Report Contest for
massage therapists and
body-workers. The goal of the context is to develop
research skills among practitioner and "enhance
their ability to provide
knowledge-based massage to
the public." The rules and guidelines are available here.
Meantime, the American Association of Naturopathic Physicianswill this year once again honor that profession's best in-office research completed by one of its members. A cash award is made available via the support of supplement company Vital Nutrients, a firm led by Rick Liva, RPH, ND, whose columns in Integrative Medicine: A Clinician's Journal, regularly explore product quality challenges.(I
have some bragging rights regarding the AANP award. I had a hand
in kicking-off the AANP's in-office research agenda and fund-raised
the cash for the first AANP award in 1991 while working with a team which
included Tori Hudson, ND, Carlo Calabrese, ND, MPH, Mark Percival, DC, ND and others on a national conference which focused on reports of in-office outcomes.